ralph 

Ralph and Jack compare and contrast speeches Ralph from LOTF and Jack from Lost both tell a speech to the whole group. Someone was more successful than the other.
      In LOTF, Ralph tries to convince everyone that they need to take their situation more seriously. He talks about how they need to work on getting rescued. He gets very mad at them. Even though he is thinking about the group, he in very bossy and not letting anyone else speak. He is also being very negative.
 
    In Lost, Jack is focussing more on surviving. He is not focusing all of his attention on just being rescued. In his speech he gets straight to the point and he doesn't talk for too long . Ralph on the other hand makes the mistake of talking for too long and loses their attention towards the end. Everyone listens to jack and they also agree with him. They all want to be rescued. They just have different ways of showing it.

     I think that jack was more successful in the end. He really gets everyone to realize that they need to work together. Jack is also much older than Ralph and he is a doctor so he will be able to take care of the others.
      I think that it’s better that Jack emerged as a leader rather than being picked because it shows that he has the potential to be a good leader. Ralph had some good ideas on how to get rescued, but he needs to get more to the point and focus more on surviving rather than just being rescued. Jack should maybe focus a little on being rescued. He is focusing ALL his attention on surviving.